Nancy Drew Books | Nancy Drew Games | Nancy Drew Auctions | Knowing Nancy Drew and Carolyn Keene | Discuss Nancy Drew

Nancy Drew Games Buy Nancy Drew Games
Support this website: Buy your games through our affiliation with Amazon. Browse Nancy Drew Games
Nancy Drew Books Buy Nancy Drew Books
Support this website: Buy your books through our affiliation with Amazon. Browse Nancy Drew Books

 [F] Nancy Drew Grownups Discussions  / Book Discussions  / Nancy Drew Girl Detective  /

#003- False Notes
 
In the third story in the series, Nancy becomes convinced that there has been a kidnapping! One of the candidates for mayor, Heather Simmons, has been acting strangely, and Nancy decides to find out why. She discovers that nobody has seen Heather's daughter around, and that she missed two days of her music camp. The deadline for filing the paperwork for a mayoral campaign is fast approaching. Will Nancy find out what's going on before it's too late?

NurseR - 05:20pm Mar 31, 2004 PST(#1 of 9)

This one is not one of my favorites. Nancy spends most of the book tracking the wrong suspect, and doesn't even consider other motives or suspects until it's too late. It also has a major problem in it with the use of George's handheld computer. Won't go into details in this post though. Suffice it to say that what she does with it is impossible at that particular moment in the story.

The other characters were well written in this one, but to me Nancy was way off. The thing with the computer and Nancy following the wrong suspect for far too long totally ruined an otherwise nice plot for me.


Girl of the Shadows - 05:22pm Apr 7, 2004 PST(#2 of 9)
Loophole in moral code: It's okay to steal a car if it belongs to your kidnappers.-The Whispering Statue

I know what you mean. The plot sounded really good, but the story seemed thin. It would have been more exciting if Leslie really had been kidnapped.


nancygurl89 - 01:42pm Apr 8, 2004 PST(#3 of 9)
Freedom is not the liberty to do as you please, but the liberty to do as you should.

~:.I agree.:~


Girl Detective#1 - 02:54pm May 31, 2004 PST(#4 of 9)

I am on the second last chapter of this book and I must say that I am fairly pleased. This book had a fair amount of action although I do agree that Nancy was way off when it came to her suspicions.


nancygurl89 - 09:51am Jun 2, 2004 PST(#5 of 9)
Freedom is not the liberty to do as you please, but the liberty to do as you should.

Yeah she was


Ghostmystery - 08:41am Jun 3, 2004 PST(#6 of 9)

Really well I guess every detective is entitled to have an off mystery but it dosen't sound like Nancy to not consider other motives and suspects did I put that right?


Hannahlady54 - 05:33pm Dec 6, 2005 PST(#7 of 9)
H is for hawiian vacations, A is for Antihomework, N is for Nancy freak, N is for Normal (okay, maybe ABnormal), A is for Athleticly challenged, H is for Hersheys lover!!!!!!!! =P

Ghost Mystery~ AWSUM NAME!!! Well, if u were in Nancy's shoes, u'd see the obvious, and the REALLY obvious, and then the 1s where it's only obvious because it wasn't obvious at first, uh, yeah.


bessfayne - 05:31pm Jan 26, 2008 PST(#8 of 9)

think its okay that nancy didnt get it i mean doing all that just 4 a scolarship was pretty exterme


aerial01 - 04:27am Apr 12, 2011 PST(#9 of 9)

well i agree with all of you.

 Read Subscriptions  Search  New User Registration  Login

 [F] Nancy Drew Grownups Discussions  / Book Discussions  / Nancy Drew Girl Detective  / #003- False Notes