The Place for Mystery Since 1995
MysteryNet Home
Mysteries
Greats
TV Movies
Books
Community

Click & buy through the ads
 
Buy through our affiliates:
•  Mystery Guild Book Club
•  Buy Books
•  Buy Games

Using Discussion

Registering (FREE—required to post)

• Subscribe   • Edit Posts   • Personal Profile


Customization & Tools (For Members)


 [F] Mystery Net Community  / Other Mystery Topics  / Learning with Mysteries  /

Does encouraging mystery reading, writing, and viewing promote crime?
 
Post your comments on this topic by typing in the box at the bottom of the page and clicking the "Post Message" button.

Previous MessagesEarliest MessagesOutlineRecent Messages (13 previous messages)
Cathe TImmons - 11:51am Dec 10, 1999 PST(#14 of 24)

Mysteries encourage thinking - problem solving - rather than passive reading. Right always triumphs over Wrong. An exception might be the "horror" books which are sometimes lumped with mysteries.


Mark Boston - 04:56am Nov 18, 2000 PST(#15 of 24)

If someone is already criminally inclined, a mystery might give them ideas. I read of safecrackers who worked behind a painted scene curtain which depicted an empty room, an idea they got from fiction. And repeated exposure to graphic violence can harden one, I believe. But most mysteries present a moral too, as the bad guy gets comeuppance.


Beth Sell - 07:04pm Dec 8, 2002 PST(#16 of 24)

If you an idoit.. Yes!


macgyvermagic - 03:44am Mar 21, 2003 PST(#17 of 24)

Sure, mysteries do give me ideas on how to kill people. I just never did it. Why? 1. Never had a reason to. 2. I know the consequences. A prison sentence doesn't fit in my life plan. Killers are already criminally inclined. You shouldn't deprive the 'normal' people of mysteries because of that. People with morals will know it's just fiction and not go on a killing spree.

It could be some criminals are inspired by mystery books/films/etc. Removing them, doesn't solve a thing.

They will be inspired by something else. BTW statistics from an earlier post where correct. Most murders happen in a spur of the moment....


Eugeniusz Nowok - 08:28am Oct 20, 2003 PST(#18 of 24)

No, i definitely do not think mystery novels promote crime in any way. I myself have been reading them for years and i know many people who have been reading them for a long time and we all r quite normal people. Crimes r commited by psychopaths and psychopaths have not been made that way, they were born that way. Psychopaths r human predetors without higher feelings and they just cannot b changed. I also dont believe at all that violent scenes on TV or violent movies can contribute to icrease crime rates in any way. I consider such views as total nonsense.


Dipa Bhagwan - 01:45pm Aug 2, 2004 PST(#19 of 24)

I'm 10 and I like to read mysteries with murder and robbery.I AM NOT VIOLENT!


Bazoo826 - 02:16pm Aug 4, 2004 PST(#20 of 24)
The nightmare before christmas is the best movie. I love Jack!

OMG i luv reading mysterys!! I dont think they encourage violence...


Susanne MacDonald - 07:51pm Nov 7, 2004 PST(#21 of 24)

You know I never did hear of murder or robbery that involved the person breaking a window to make it LOOK like they escaped out that way, or used piano wire to lock doors...

Most Criminals are not smart, just lucky sometimes...So obviously they haven't been reading mystery novels..


can't catch me - 01:56pm Dec 16, 2004 PST(#22 of 24)

Hey if a criminal was really clever, and DID get the idea from a book, they'd #1 get away with it and then #2 never tell you. So we truly do not know if it happens; whether the actual "cause" is reading them or not, that's another topic entirely. Promoting literature and literacy of ANY kind most likely doesn't promote crime! If anything, will just give criminals better spelling. ha ha ha


Valerie Kitsune - 02:04pm Feb 19, 2005 PST(#23 of 24)

heck i wouldn't be able to stand all these goody tooshoo books when everyone has a perfect life and nothing goes on thats exciting. I need excitement and sometimes mysteries and crimes help your education sometimes. They help you think and use your imagination and lately it seems that's what people want us to do. If people want to go out there and use the author's ideas, if they read through the book to the end, they know the consequences of their actions. If they are going to take away crime and mystery books cause they promote violence, they haven't seen what has been going on tv then.


Michael Allen - 02:45am Jan 12, 2008 PST(#24 of 24)

Good question if mysteries cuase people to be criminals, I wonder what books Dick Cheney and George W. Bush have read.

 Read Subscriptions  Search  New User Registration  Login

 [F] Mystery Net Community  / Other Mystery Topics  / Learning with Mysteries  / Does encouraging mystery reading, writing, and viewing promote crime?

In Association with Amazon.com

Support MysteryNet

Start Your Amazon
Shopping Here: